Digital vs Analogue
Why switch to 406?
What if 121.5 MHz distress beacons are used after 1 February 2009?
A comparison of 406 MHz vs 121.5 MHz distress beacons.
Why switch to 406?
From 1 February 2009 Cospas-Sarsat satellites
will no longer detect 121.5 MHz distress
beacons.
Major advantages of switching to a 406 MHz
distress beacon are:
- their improved accuracy - especially those
that are GPS capable;
- the capability for search and rescue
authorities to determine whether the alert is
legitimate – for those that are registered, a
simple phone call can determine this; and
- a faster response – valuable information
about those in distress and the distress
location can be gained by rescue authorities
contacting friends and family nominated as
emergency contacts.
It is estimated that there are some 150,000
121.5 MHz distress beacons that will need to
be switched over to 406 MHz beacons and
expectations are that demand will outstrip
supply, leaving many distress beacon owners
without the appropriate beacon. Distress
beacon owners are encouraged to make the
switch now or risk not having the required
safety equipment when it is needed most
^
What if 121.5 MHz distress beacons are used after 1 February 2009?
With the satellite system no longer receiving
alerts from 121.5 MHz from 1 February 2009,
over-flying aircraft will be the only means of
detecting activated analogue beacons. In some
areas within the Australian search and rescue
region this could amount to days rather than
hours before a 121.5 MHz beacon could be
heard. In some circumstances, the 121.5 MHz
beacon may not be detected at all. Not all
aircraft ‘listen’ to the 121.5 MHz frequency and
those that do are generally very high flyers. As
a consequence, the search area resulting from
these detections could be very large and it would
take rescue authorities considerable time and
resources to localise the distress signal. This
would also apply to distress beacons activated
directly under a well used flight path.
^
A comparison of 406 MHz vs 121.5 MHz distress beacons.
|
406 beacon |
121.5 beacon |
Signal type |
Digital |
Analogue |
Coverage |
The entire globe |
Australian land mass and about 900 to 1500 km from the coast. |
Identification |
406 beacons have a unique identification code
which is part of its signal. |
121.5 beacons are anonymous. They don't tell rescue authorities
who's in trouble, or even what's in trouble. |
When properly registered with the Rescue Coordination Centre,
Australia, the unique code provides information
about the boat or aircraft, or person carrying the beacon.
This includes the owner's emergency contact and the country of
registration. |
|
| Allows false alarms to be resolved with a radio
or phone call. |
Only about 3 in every 100 alerts are genuine. The rest come
from:
- Accidental & malicious activation
- Faulty beacons
- Aeroplanes
- Power transformers
- Other electronic equipment
- Unusual atmospheric conditions
All alarms must be tracked to the source.
False alerts waste the valuable time and resources of rescue
organisations and volunteers. |
Alert time |
The 406 signal may be received within seconds by Geostationary
satellites. If detected by a polar orbiting satellite, detection
time will be longer. The extra information provided by a 406 will
in most cases help authorities locate you faster. |
Orbiting satellites take 90 minutes on average to receive the signal
but it may take up to 5 hours depending on the conditions.
Processing the 121.5 signal may take an additional 45
minutes . |
Location |
Accurate to 5 km.
Some 406 beacons use Global Positioning System (GPS) and have an accuracy
of 120 metres. An accurate location can be determined
with the pass of 1 satellite 95% of the time. |
Accurate to 20 km More information is needed
to determine the real location. This usually means at least 2
satellite passes &/or independent intelligence
is required to determine a location and this takes more
time. |
Rescue time |
If the 406 beacon is registered, it will enable rescuers to know
more about who you are, where you are, what your boat/plane looks
like, and your emergency contact. This saves time, and therefore helps
rescuers to act more quickly. |
Rescuers must wait for confirmation of the beacon's position before
sending a search & rescue team. This takes more time. |
Signal Power |
5 Watts |
0.1 Watt |
Future Technology |
406 beacons are the direction of the future in beacon technology. |
From February 2009 the international satellite system (called
Cospas-Sarsat) will no longer process the 121.5 signal. This will
make all 121.5 beacons obsolete. Owners of the 121.5 beacon should work towards upgrading to the
406 at their next beacon battery changeover. |
^
|